Beginner mistakes with stocks: five typical mistakes and how rules help
Typical beginner mistakes with stocks are: buying without a plan, following tips and headlines, letting losses run and taking profits too early, diversifying too little or reallocating too often, and constantly checking the portfolio. For each of these mistakes there is a rule you can set in advance. No rule prevents losses, but it makes decisions traceable.
In short
- A plan sets in advance what you select by and when you get out again.
- Private investors prefer to buy stocks that are currently getting attention (Barber and Odean, 2008).
- Selling winners too early and holding losers too long is called the disposition effect in research.
- Frequent reallocating costs fees. In a large US study, the most active accounts performed worse than the market.
- A fixed review date replaces constantly looking at the portfolio.
As of 11/16/2026
One criterion for all securities, re-sorted once a day.
Go to the scannerMistake 1: Buying without a plan
The first purchase often happens spontaneously. A stock is mentioned among friends, the price has just risen, so you buy. What's missing are three answers: why this security? How much money? When do you get out again?
In its "basics of investing", Germany's financial regulator BaFin advises only investing in products you understand, checking the costs in advance and not letting yourself be pressured into a deal. At its core, that is a plan.
The rule against it: before buying, write down by which criterion you select and which condition leads to an exit. The RSL strategy as RSL-scan describes it is an example of such a fixed framework: selection by rank, exit by rank and RSL. A plan can be wrong too. It only ensures that later you know why you decided as you did.
Mistake 2: Following tips and headlines
In 2008, Brad Barber and Terrance Odean showed that private investors mainly buy stocks that are currently attracting attention: securities in the news, with unusually high trading volume or with an extreme daily move. The reason is simple. There are thousands of stocks, and you can't check them all. So what is loud right now makes the shortlist.
The problem: attention is not a selection criterion. A tip doesn't tell you why a security should be better than the others in the same market.
The rule against it: one criterion for all securities. A ranking, for example, sorts all securities of an index by the same metric, such as the relative strength Robert Levy described in 1967. That way you see a security in comparison with the rest instead of on its own. However, the ranking only describes how prices have developed recently. It doesn't show whether a company is run well. More on this on the page How do I find good stocks?
Instead of headlines: all securities of an index by the same metric.
View the rankingMistake 3: Letting losses run, taking profits too early
One security is down 20%. Selling feels like an admission, so you wait. Another is up 10%, and you sell quickly to keep the gain (sample figures). In 1985, Hersh Shefrin and Meir Statman described this pattern as the disposition effect: investors tend to sell winners too early and hold losers too long.
The rule against it: an exit rule that is fixed before the purchase. In the RSL strategy as RSL-scan describes it, a position is held as long as it is in the top 25% of its index and its RSL is above 1. If either condition no longer holds, the strategy calls for selling. The rule moves the decision to before the purchase, away from the heat of the moment. But it can also lead to sales after which the price rises again, and every switch costs fees. More on this under exit rules and in the comparison stop-loss or rule-based exit.
Mistake 4: Too little diversification, too many reallocations
Two mistakes that go in opposite directions. The first: putting everything on one or two securities. BaFin calls the remedy "don't put everything on one card": spreading limits the risk that a single total loss hits your entire wealth. But diversification doesn't prevent losses when the whole market falls.
The second: constantly reallocating. In 2000, Barber and Odean analyzed the accounts of 66,465 US households from 1991 to 1996. The households that traded the most performed significantly worse than the overall market. The authors name overconfidence as one explanation.
The rule against it: a fixed number of equally sized positions and a fixed reason for switching. The RSL strategy as RSL-scan describes it on the method page works with about five equally weighted positions and only switches when an exit rule applies. Five securities is a small number, though, and according to the strategy page, concentrating on the strongest securities brings higher fluctuations. How many securities suit you is a personal decision. More on this under How many stocks belong in a portfolio?
Mistake 5: Constantly checking
The app shows a new number every day. Sometimes red, sometimes green. In 1995, Shlomo Benartzi and Richard Thaler described "myopic loss aversion": investors are sensitive to losses and evaluate their portfolio frequently, even if they have long-term goals. If you look often, you see a loss more often and are more likely to act on the spur of the moment.
The rule against it: a fixed review date. On the 26-week basis, the RSL strategy as RSL-scan describes it provides for one check per week. You put securities you want to watch on a watchlist and look at them on the fixed date. Looking less often doesn't change prices. It only changes how often you are tempted to act. More on this under How often should you check your portfolio?
One look on a fixed date. The ranking changes once a day.
Go to the scannerWhat rules can and can't do
Rules make decisions repeatable and verifiable. They don't prevent losses, they don't provide a forecast, and a rule that fit in the past may work worse in the future. According to the strategy page, the RSL strategy as RSL-scan describes it, being a momentum strategy, works best in rising markets and can be weaker in sideways and falling phases.
If you're at the very beginning, the page Stocks for beginners covers the basics before that: emergency reserve, time horizon and the question of whether individual stocks suit you at all.
Method and author
RSL-scan editorial team. RSL-scan is a paid analysis tool (Light and Premium subscriptions); the top places of the ranking are visible without a subscription. RSL-scan ranks securities by relative strength (Levy RSL) within one market. The rankings are re-sorted once a day. No forecast. The basis is the ratio from R. A. Levy, "Relative Strength as a Criterion for Investment Selection", Journal of Finance, 1967. RSL-scan calculates with 26 weeks or 26 days. All figures on this page are sample values or placeholders. As of 11/16/2026.
Frequently asked questions
What are typical mistakes with stocks?
Five patterns are typical: buying without a plan, following tips and headlines, letting losses run and taking profits too early, diversifying too little or reallocating too often, and constantly checking the portfolio. Several of them are described in research on investor behavior.
What mistakes do beginners make when buying stocks?
When buying, a plan is often missing: no clear selection criterion, no fixed position size and no exit rule. On top of that, stocks that are currently in the news tend to be bought.
What mistakes are there in stock trading?
Trading is mainly about buying and selling too often. Every order costs fees. In a study by Barber and Odean (US data 1991 to 1996), the households that traded the most performed significantly worse than the overall market.
How do I avoid beginner mistakes when buying stocks?
Before buying, decide what you select by, how much money goes into a position and when you get out again. Check on a fixed date instead of constantly. That doesn't prevent losses, but it makes decisions traceable.
What tips are there for beginners on the stock market?
We don't name individual stocks. Regulators such as BaFin give general basic rules: build an emergency reserve, don't put everything on one card, only buy products you understand and check costs in advance.
Is it a mistake to sit out losses?
Not automatically. It becomes a mistake when you only wait because selling feels like an admission. An exit rule that is fixed before the purchase takes this decision out of the moment. It can also be wrong in an individual case.
Sources
- Levy, Robert A. (1967): "Relative Strength as a Criterion for Investment Selection". The Journal of Finance, vol. 22, no. 4, pp. 595-610. DOI 10.1111/j.1540-6261.1967.tb00295.x. Summary: RePEc: Relative Strength as a Criterion for Investment Selection. Origin of the relative strength ratio (RSL), not of RSL-scan's rules.
- RSL-scan, home page and FAQ: RSL-scan. Ranking by relative strength (Levy RSL) within one market, re-sorting once a day, no forecast, watchlist, Light and Premium subscriptions.
- RSL-scan, strategy page: RSL-scan: Strategy. Entry and exit rules (top 25% and RSL above 1), about five equally weighted positions, weekly check on the 26-week basis, higher volatility from concentration, transaction costs, weaker phases in bear markets and sideways phases.
- BaFin: Das kleine Einmaleins der Geldanlage (in German). Emergency reserve, don't put everything on one card, only products you understand, check costs, don't let yourself be pressured.
- Barber, Brad M.; Odean, Terrance (2008): "All That Glitters: The Effect of Attention and News on the Buying Behavior of Individual and Institutional Investors". The Review of Financial Studies, vol. 21, no. 2, pp. 785-818. DOI 10.1093/rfs/hhm079. Summary: RePEc: All That Glitters.
- Barber, Brad M.; Odean, Terrance (2000): "Trading Is Hazardous to Your Wealth: The Common Stock Investment Performance of Individual Investors". The Journal of Finance, vol. 55, no. 2, pp. 773-806. DOI 10.1111/0022-1082.00226. Summary: RePEc: Trading Is Hazardous to Your Wealth.
- Shefrin, Hersh; Statman, Meir (1985): "The Disposition to Sell Winners Too Early and Ride Losers Too Long: Theory and Evidence". The Journal of Finance, vol. 40, no. 3, pp. 777-790. DOI 10.1111/j.1540-6261.1985.tb05002.x.
- Benartzi, Shlomo; Thaler, Richard H. (1995): "Myopic Loss Aversion and the Equity Premium Puzzle". The Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 110, no. 1, pp. 73-92. DOI 10.2307/2118511. Summary: NBER Working Paper 4369.
- All percentages in the text (20% loss, 10% gain) are sample figures.
Rules instead of gut feeling. No forecast, no recommendation.
Go to the scannerNot a buy recommendation. Not investment advice. Investments carry risks of loss up to and including total loss. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.